Differences Between Bitcoin Spot ETF and Futures ETF

Communication and Sharing.

What is an ETF?

An Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is an investment fund, similar to stocks, traded on a stock exchange. These funds typically hold a variety of assets such as stocks, commodities, or cryptocurrencies, aiming to track the performance of specific indices or assets.

Unlike mutual funds, which calculate Net Asset Value (NAV) at the end of each trading day, ETFs trade on the stock exchange throughout the trading day at market prices that fluctuate with supply and demand.

Although ETF NAVs are calculated multiple times during the trading day, investors still trade based on market prices. This provides investors with greater liquidity and flexibility compared to mutual funds. Additionally, investors can employ various trading strategies such as short selling or margin trading, which are not commonly available with mutual funds.

What is a Bitcoin ETF?

A Bitcoin ETF is an important financial instrument in the cryptocurrency investment realm, providing investors with a way to participate in Bitcoin price fluctuations without directly holding or managing Bitcoin. It operates similarly to traditional stocks, holding either Bitcoin or contracts related to Bitcoin prices and traded on a securities exchange. With the development of the cryptocurrency market, Bitcoin ETFs have gained popularity among investors, especially two main types: Bitcoin Spot ETFs and Bitcoin Futures ETFs, catering to different investment strategies and risk preferences.

What is a Bitcoin Spot ETF?

A Bitcoin Spot ETF is an exchange-traded fund that directly holds Bitcoin as its underlying asset. This means that the performance of a spot ETF is directly linked to the real-time value of the Bitcoin it holds. When investors purchase shares of a spot ETF, they are essentially buying Bitcoin, albeit without directly holding Bitcoin themselves.

For example, suppose there is a Bitcoin Spot ETF called "BTC-one." If BTC-One holds 10,000 Bitcoins and issues 1 million shares, theoretically, each share represents ownership of 0.01 Bitcoin. This means that the performance of BTC-One is directly correlated with the real-time value of the Bitcoin it holds.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Bitcoin Spot ETF

Investing in a Bitcoin Spot ETF offers several advantages. Firstly, it allows investors to benefit from Bitcoin price fluctuations without the need to manage or store Bitcoin themselves, eliminating concerns about security and digital wallets. Secondly, since these ETFs trade on traditional securities exchanges, Bitcoin is brought into the regulatory framework, increasing trust among investors. Lastly, for traditional investors, investing in Bitcoin Spot ETFs is simpler because it operates within the familiar framework of stock trading.

However, like any investment, Bitcoin Spot ETFs also carry some potential risks. Firstly, the value of the ETF will fluctuate with Bitcoin's price movements. Secondly, due to associated fees or management issues, the performance of ETFs may not always align perfectly with Bitcoin. Despite ETFs bridging Bitcoin with traditional finance and regulation, the cryptocurrency market remains unpredictable. Finally, since trading ETFs entails additional fees, the costs of trading ETFs are higher compared to trading spot cryptocurrencies directly. ETF-related fees can be as high as 2.5%, whereas the costs of trading spot cryptocurrencies are typically much lower.

What is a Bitcoin Futures ETF?

A Bitcoin Futures ETF is an exchange-traded fund that does not directly hold Bitcoin but instead invests in Bitcoin futures contracts. These contracts allow buying or selling Bitcoin at a predetermined price on a future date. Therefore, investors can speculate on Bitcoin's future price fluctuations without holding Bitcoin directly.

For example, let's consider "BitFutures" as a Bitcoin Futures ETF. It aims to track Bitcoin's future prices by purchasing Bitcoin futures contracts. The ETF is established and managed by a financial institution. Investors can purchase shares of "BitFutures" on regular securities exchanges, just like buying shares of other companies. Each share represents ownership of the potential profits (or losses) from these contracts.

When you purchase shares of a Bitcoin Futures ETF like "BitFutures," you are essentially indirectly betting on Bitcoin's future prices rather than holding cryptocurrency or futures contracts directly. What you are buying is a part of the fund holding these contracts.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Bitcoin Futures ETF

Bitcoin Futures ETFs share similar advantages with Bitcoin Spot ETFs. They enable investors to profit from Bitcoin price fluctuations without directly purchasing or managing Bitcoin. They also operate in regulated environments, complying with standards set by financial regulatory bodies, which enhances investor confidence. Additionally, they provide higher liquidity compared to other investment tools, allowing investors to easily buy and sell ETF shares on traditional securities exchanges.

However, Bitcoin Futures ETFs also have some disadvantages and risks. One of them is that they do not offer direct exposure to Bitcoin. Investors in Bitcoin Futures ETFs do not directly hold Bitcoin but hold shares of funds invested in futures contracts. This requires investors to understand the complexity of futures markets, as the performance of ETFs is closely tied to the futures market. Additionally, apart from extra management fees, the value of Bitcoin Futures ETFs may not always closely follow Bitcoin's price movements and may be affected by counterparty risks since the counterparties in futures contracts may fail to meet contract obligations.

Main Differences Between Bitcoin Spot ETF and Futures ETF